afraid the gays are going to out-breed you (not even kidding, they really “think” that)

Do, uh, do they understand how reproduction works, or…?

afraid what you want won’t be what everyone does, afraid other people are smarter or more capable

Well, yeah, that's almost certainly true.

afraid that when you die you won’t get magicked somewhere to live forever.

Atheists would say that's true too.